Loading...
01-15-2019 City Council Study Session Packet City of Grand Island Tuesday, January 15, 2019 Study Session Packet City Council: Jason Conley Michelle Fitzke Chuck Haase Julie Hehnke Jeremy Jones Vaughn Minton Mitchell Nickerson Mike Paulick Clay Schutz Mark Stelk Mayor: Roger G. Steele City Administrator: Marlan Ferguson City Clerk: RaNae Edwards 7:00 PM Council Chambers - City Hall 100 East 1st Street, Grand Island, NE 68801 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 1 / 110 City of Grand Island Tuesday, January 15, 2019 Call to Order This is an open meeting of the Grand Island City Council. The City of Grand Island abides by the Open Meetings Act in conducting business. A copy of the Open Meetings Act is displayed in the back of this room as required by state law. The City Council may vote to go into Closed Session on any agenda item as allowed by state law. Invocation Pledge of Allegiance Roll Call A - SUBMITTAL OF REQUESTS FOR FUTURE ITEMS Individuals who have appropriate items for City Council consideration should complete the Request for Future Agenda Items form located at the Information Booth. If the issue can be handled administratively without Council action, notification will be provided. If the item is scheduled for a meeting or study session, notification of the date will be given. B - RESERVE TIME TO SPEAK ON AGENDA ITEMS This is an opportunity for individuals wishing to provide input on any of tonight's agenda items to reserve time to speak. Please come forward, state your name and address, and the Agenda topic on which you will be speaking. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 2 / 110 City of Grand Island Tuesday, January 15, 2019 Study Session Item -1 Friends of the Grand Island Parks Presentation Staff Contact: Todd McCoy, Parks & Recreation Director Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 3 / 110 FRIENDS OF GRAND ISLAND PARKS Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 4 / 110 WHY FRIENDS OF GRAND ISLAND PARKS? In July of 2017, the proposed City of Grand Island’s 2018 Budget had a huge impact on the gardens in the city’s parks. •Recommended cuts included elimination of the city greenhouse, the horticulturist’s position, and seasonal help for the horticulturist. •Once the dust settled, the greenhouse and the horticulturist’s position were saved but approximately $15,000 in funding for all seasonal help was eliminated. •Hence in a REACTION to these cuts, Friends of Grand Island Parks was born. •Which means last summer you saw flowers in the parks, at City Hall, the City Cemetery, Island Oasis, and the Heartland Shooting Park only because of the support provided by Friends of Grand Island Parks Volunteers. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 5 / 110 THE MEASURE OF ANY GREAT CIVILIZATION IS ITS CITIES AND THE MEASURE OF A CITY’S GREATNESS IS TO BE FOUND IN THE QUALITY OF ITS PUBLIC SPACES, ITS PARKS AND SQUARES. JOHN RUSKIN, ENGLISH WRITER AND ART CRITIC Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 6 / 110 AFTER HOURS OF RESEARCH AND DISCUSSIONS, WE DEFINED OUR BELIEFS A group of concerned citizens who envision a well- balance park system. Friends of Grand Island Parks believe that a healthy park system: •supports the rejuvenation of the body, mind, and spirit, •contributes to inclusivity and democracy, •ensures gathering spaces that help to build community and contribute to neighborhood safety, •promotes equitably distributed resources between parks and recreation, •promotes the health and balance between urban and natural environments, •forms part of a healthy economic base for our neighborhoods and the city, •nurtures healthy relationships with family, community, and the environment around us, •creates a legacy through education, history, and community partnerships. Friends of Grand Island Parks. . . Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 7 / 110 The Mission of Friends of Grand Island Parks is to provide support to the City of Grand Island in order to assist in developing, maintaining, and increasing the value and importance of city parks as a place of natural beauty, culture, recreation and education for this and future generations. FGIP is a nonprofit fund sponsored by the Grand Island Community Foundation. Mission of Friends of Grand Island Parks. . . Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 8 / 110 “PARKS AND PLAYGROUNDS ARE THE SOUL OF A CITY” It has been said. . . Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 9 / 110 TAKE A MOMENT TO THINK - Assume the role of a newcomer to Grand Island, gather a mental picture as you think of these parks? Ashley Park Augustine Park Broadwell Park Buechler Park Cedar Hills Park Eagle Scout Park George Park Grace Abbott Park L.E. Ray Park Lincoln Park Lions Club Park Memorial Park Pier Park Pioneer Park Ryder Park Henry Schuff Park Sothman Park Sterling Estates Park Stolley Park Suck’s Lake/Park Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 10 / 110 WHAT DO OUR PARKS TELL OUR CITIZENS AND OUR VISITORS ABOUT GRAND ISLAND? It has been said. . . You can get the true essence of a city just by hanging out in their parks! Knowing that. . . Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 11 / 110 Vision of Friends of Grand Island Parks. . . providing, protecting, and preserving parks for enjoyment, education, and inspiration, cultivating experiences focusing on health, enjoyment, fun, and learning for people of all ages and abilities, serving as a cultural, educational, and recreational resource, connecting people to the land and each other, developing, beautifying, maintaining, restoring and preserving passive and active leisure pursuits and opportunities, celebrating Grand Island’s natural, cultural, artistic, historical, and recreational resources, by providing well-maintained and safe parks that meet the needs of individuals, families, and the community. The Vision of Friends of Grand Island Parks is to assist in developing, maintaining, and increasing the value and importance of city parks to ensure these parks are part of daily life for this and future generation and, in turn, shape the character of the Grand Island area by: Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 12 / 110 WHY BRING OUR VISION TO LIFE? We’ve discovered parks are: •A reflection of the quality of life in a community, •A source of positive economic benefits, enhanced property values, and generated money for the local economy. •Gathering places for families and social groups, •A way to build relationships, and promote social interaction, •A measurable physical and mental health benefit, •Alternative hands-on learning environments for young people of all ages and abilities, •An important setting for promoting arts and cultural programs, •A sense of community pride. •One of the top three reasons that businesses use in relocation decisions. This is where it gets exciting! Friends of G.I. Parks have done a bit of research to explore parks and botanical plantings that draw large numbers of visitors like the Heritage Trails Quilt Gardens in Elkhart County, Indiana. We’ve also visited parks in almost every state and several foreign countries but we’ve paid special attention to parks in Nebraska, South Dakota, Iowa, Colorado, and New Mexico. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 13 / 110 Perhaps, Sharon Roerty, Senior Program Officer of Robert Wood Johnson Foundation said it best - “The power of parks is that they transcend age, ethnicity, race, income, politics and geography. You know a park is working when you show up on a Sunday, or better yet any day, and see people on a bike or on foot, playing games or activities that celebrate culture. Parks give us freedom to explore and to discover, to see butterflies, birds, and other animals. Parks are a necessary part of our culture and humanity - they provide the free space to play, to gather, or to simply be by yourself. Parks meet our need to connect with nature. They feed our souls. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 14 / 110 SO WHAT DOES THAT MEAN FOR GRAND ISLAND? Friends of G.I. Parks decided we need to look beyond weeding flowerbeds. If we want to join in the efforts to Grow Grand Island we need to become PROACTIVE and DREAM BIG! We want to do much more than be satisfied with status quo. Our DREAM is to make G.I. the DESTINATION SITE if you want to see GORGEOUS PARKS with AMAZING ART! We know that success breeds success. With everyone working together, not only will we grow a bigger sense of community but our passion and pride in G.I. will be visible to our citizens and our visitors! Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 15 / 110 WE START BY REVITALIZING STOLLEY PARK Where we help the past step into the present and become the future! Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 16 / 110 HERE’S THE VISION The current 4 large gardens will be made into 8 smaller “themed” gardens with additional paths made from pavers and crushed rock. Each garden will have artwork reflecting the garden’s theme. The Stolley garden will have additional lighting along the pathways and uplighting artwork. Pathways are handicapped accessible and give visitors the chance to have a closer view of the plants and artwork. Signs will be found throughout the garden to identify plants as well as donors to the Stolley Garden Project. Our early donors include Vlcek Gardens, Sheffield Tree Service, Tilley’s Sprinklers, Jim Cannon, and Conda Allen Photography. Also recognized will be supporters including Ken Gnadt, the Grand Island Independent, G.I. Northwest High School’s Alternative Education Program along with FGIP volunteers. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 17 / 110 THE GARDENS AT STOLLEY Themes of the eight gardens at Stolley Parks include the: •A-B-C Garden containing plants with names representative of the alphabet. The sculpture in this garden will be “kid friendly” allowing children to interact with the sculpture as they explore the garden. •Kaleidoscope Garden consisting of plants that reflect a prism of nature’s palette. This is another garden that will invite children to explore the colors of nature as well as the sculpture located there. •Sensory Garden incorporating plants and other elements that provide garden visitors of all ages with the opportunity to be immersed in the scents, textures, and colors of plants. •Pollinator Garden has an environment that is designed for the growth, development, and feeding of butterflies and other flying insects. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 18 / 110 THE GARDENS AT STOLLEY, CONTINUED The remaining four themes for the gardens at Stolley Parks include the: •Vintage Garden composed of a variety of plants that would have been found in the gardens of the Stolley family and their neighbors. •Healing Garden combining a variety of plants and herbs used by early settlers as well as modern-day individuals who are interested in exploring the growing role of nature in healing and wellness. •Peace Garden providing an inspirational way to honor our veterans as well as pay tribute to the life of a loved one, while providing a quiet place to remember. Visitors will enjoy the sound of water from artwork that includes a water feature complete with a paver bridge. The Peace Garden will include memorial benches, pavers, and flowers such as Forget-Me-Nots. •Vintage Rose Garden composed of Heirloom Roses that require low maintenance and are disease resistant yet provide the perfect backdrop for the Celebration Circle. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 19 / 110 A-B-C and Pollinator Gardens Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 20 / 110 Kaleidoscope Garden Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 21 / 110 Sensory Garden Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 22 / 110 Healing, Sensory, Vintage and Peace Gardens Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 23 / 110 We’re adding something new: A Celebration Circle The west end of the garden will include an area that has been extended to include pavers in the shape of a circle suitable for additional seating or tables. Also included in this new area is a stage, a raised brick ledge for additional seating, and at the old-fashioned rose garden. This area would be ideal for special events such as weddings, anniversary celebrations, marriage proposals, or weekend concerts/performances. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 24 / 110 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 25 / 110 STOLLEY PARK IS JUST THE BEGINNING FGIP plans on “growing” an endowed fund to support the G.I. parks, ensuring a sound future that includes: •Scheduling special events that bring families and other community members together like the free outdoor movie nights started last year at Grace Abbott Park by Jeremy and Alexia Fields. •Partnering with the City Library to provide story walks in the parks where families can read children books as they walk together through the park. •Adding other Grand Island parks in our vision to include artwork in the flowerbeds. •Working with the Grow Grand Island Arts and Humanities committee as we “grow” our vision of making the greater Grand Island area a destination location for visiting amazing gardens and sculptures. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 26 / 110 VOLUNTEERS HELP MAKE THIS ALL POSSIBLE •During the fall and winter, volunteers are the backbone of the city greenhouse. Greenhouse Volunteers assist the City Horticulturist with tasks such as potting and repotting of plants; plant propagation or care and maintenance of annuals and perennials. •Once spring hits, volunteers move outside and begin planting and caring for the flowerbeds found in nine locations across the city including: Island Oasis, Pier Park, Memorial Park, Schuff’s Park, Grace Abbott Park, City Hall, Pioneer Park and City Cemetery. •In addition to the flowerbeds, volunteers also plant over 80 flowerpots that are located at City Hall, Heartland Shooting Park, and Island Oasis. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 27 / 110 This past year over 87 individuals volunteered more than 4,100 hours. This amounts to a donation of approximately $36,900 to the City of Grand Island. It’s important to know, 28 of those volunteers are adults with disabilities who are provided with real life occupational experiences. However, as we reflect on this year we’ve learned that, as great as volunteers are, we can’t count on them to work a regular daily or hourly schedule and replace hired seasonal employees. This is especially true during the hot, humid summer months when our volunteer numbers drop markedly and when we really need their help to maintain the flowerbeds. With that in mind, we will continue to urge the city to find a way to include an additional $15,000 in the Parks and Recreation budget which is the approximate cost necessary to fund the hiring of 2-3 seasonal employees. FGIP VOLUNTEERS ARE PRICELESS! Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 28 / 110 FGIP GOALS ACCOMPLISHED •Built a foundation of donors who have helped with the Stolley Park Revitalization Project including Vlcek Gardens, Sheffield Tree Service, Tilley’s Sprinklers, and Jim Cannon. •Began work on PR and marketing strategies by giving presentations to local service groups and organizations using the photography of Conda Sorensen Allen. •Rebuilt the interior of the city greenhouse to ensure the safety of the volunteers who work there. •Maintained all the propagation and plantings in the city parks, the City Cemetery, Island Oasis, the Heartland Shooting Park, and City Hall. •Began a partnership with the City Library looking toward the development of Story Walks in designated parks. •Obtained our 501c3 Nonprofit status by applying for and becoming a fund sponsored by the GI Community Foundation. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 29 / 110 GOALS FOR NEXT SPRING. . . Build a bigger volunteer base Continue to urge the city to find the funding for full time and part time seasonal garden help Work on our FGIP Strategic Plan Begin scheduling themed events in the parks during the spring and summer Begin a capital campaign for FGIP Begin work on accumulating funds for an endowment that will support FGIP Watch for the article in NE Life Magazine featuring F.G.I.P. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 30 / 110 MORE GOALS FOR NEXT SPRING. . . Begin work on the Stolley project Work on Stolley infrastructure including lights, a water feature, restore pavers and pathways to be handicapped accessible and safe, install watering system for the garden, replace benches, and repair existing gazebos Begin work on the Celebration Circle, wall, rose garden and Celebration Stage Complete one or more themed gardens with sculptures Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 31 / 110 WE INVITE YOU TO JOIN US ON A VIRTUAL REALITY TOUR OF THE NEW STOLLEY PARK. FOLLOWING THAT WE’LL SPEND SOME TIME WITH YOUR QUESTIONS. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 32 / 110 ANY DAY SPENT IN THE PARK IS A GOOD DAY! Questions / Comments Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 33 / 110 Friends of Grand Island Parks Steering Committee: •Ann Marsh •Ben Wassinger •Duane Woodward •Kathy McFarland •Jan Tell •Ken Tell •Larry Cast •Terry Slips •Vikki Deuel •Jeremy Fields •Alexia Fields •Brad Foster We may be a committee of a few but we always welcome anyone with a sense of community pride and the passion for making a difference! Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 34 / 110 City of Grand Island Tuesday, January 15, 2019 Study Session Item -2 Tax Increment Financing (TIF) Processes and Procedures in Grand Island Staff Contact: Chad Nabity Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 35 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Tax Increment Financing Processes and Procedures In Grand Island January 15, 2019 Chad Nabity, AICP Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 36 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Tax Increment Financing (TIF) 1. What is it? What is the Process for a TIF Application? What is the impact of using it? How has it been used in Grand Island? When should TIF be used? Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 37 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY What is TIF? It is a method authorized by the Nebraska Constitution that allows cities to use an increase in real estate taxes to rehabilitate substandard and blighted areas. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 38 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Substandard and Blight Substandard means generally an area in which there is: …a predominance of improvements which are dilapidated, deteriorated, old, obsolete overcrowded and which is detrimental to public health, safety, morals or welfare. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 39 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Substandard and Blight 2. Blighted means generally an area in which there are: …deteriorated structures, defective or inadequate street layout, faulty lot layout, insanitary or unsafe conditions, diversity of ownership, improper or obsolete platting, existence of conditions which endanger life or property by fire or other causes, or any combination which substantially impairs the sound growth of the community, retards the provision of housing or constitutes an economic or social liability and is detrimental to public health, safety, morals or welfare; AND Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 40 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Substandard and Blight Continued: Has one of these: Average age of structures more than 40 years; unemployment 120% of state average; more than 1/2 of plotted land has been undeveloped and in city limits for 40 years; per capita income is lower than city average; or area has had stable or decreasing population based on census. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 41 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Substandard and Blight 1.Area can include bare property if impacted by other conditions. 2.Does not mean every building is in poor condition. 3.Declaration of substandard and blight is not registered in register of deeds office nor the assessors office. 4.No history of a negative impact on value of property nor sales price. 5.Terms are established in the Nebraska constitution and can only be changed by a vote of the people. 6.Cannot blight more than 35% of geographical limits. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 42 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Process for Declaring an area of the City Substandard and Blighted Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 43 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Process for Declaring an area of the City Substandard and Blighted Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 44 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Before a TIF Application is Considered 1.Meet with CRA Staff and others if needed to discuss project 2.Has the Area been declared blighted and substandard? 3.Is the proposed project consistent with the comprehensive plan? 4.How much of an increment will be created? 5.What are the eligible expenditures? Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 45 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY TIF Approval Process Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 46 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY “But for test” 1.TIF is not a matter of right, but a matter of legislative and administrative decision. 2.TIF cannot be authorized unless the project is one which: a.would not occur in the substandard and blighted area without TIF, and b.is not financially feasible without TIF. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 47 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Cost Benefit Analysis Before recommending approval of a redevelopment plan to the council, the CRA must undertake a cost benefit analysis consisting of the following factors” Whether the project results in a tax shift. Public infrastructure and public service needs and local tax impacts. Impacts on employers and employees within the project area. Impacts on employers and employees within and outside the city. Impacts on student populations of school districts. Any other impacts determined to be relevant. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 48 / 110 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 49 / 110 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 50 / 110 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 51 / 110 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 52 / 110 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 53 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY About the TIF Bond 1.No liability on City or Tax Payers to pay TIF debt…only payment is from increased taxes on redevelopment project. 2.If increased taxes are insufficient to pay off TIF debt, bond is cancelled at end of 15 years with no further liability. 3.If taxes are higher than expected and TIF debt is paid off prior to 15 years, balance of taxes are returned to treasurer for payment to taxing entities. 4.Generally the developer purchases the TIF debt and takes risk of being paid. 5.Generally interest on TIF debt is taxable. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 54 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Limitation of uses of TIF 1.Buy real property. 2.Demolition and site preparation. 3.Install streets, utilities, parks, public spaces, over and under passes. 4.Public parking facilities and convention centers, lighting, shelters and benches. 5.Costs for planning, design and engineering. 6.Costs incurred by city. 7.Rehabilitation of existing structures [Cannot build new buildings]. 8.Workforce Housing Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 55 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Purpose of the CRA . The CRA is charged with taking action in specified areas of the community to remove, prevent or inhibit physical deterioration (blighted and substandard conditions) that will result in lower property values and create disincentives to private investment. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 56 / 110 COMMUNITY REDEVELOPME NT AUTHORITY Possible Goal Statements for the Use of TIF Preserve the Downtown Core Retain and Attract Retail Development Create Base Employment Support Infill Development Use Micro Blight and Small Projects to Remove and Remediate Problem Properties Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 57 / 110 How long does it take to use tax- increment financing? Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 58 / 110 Well . . . It’s not exactly fast. But there’s a good reason why. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 59 / 110 Public Involvement! Electeds & General Public Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 60 / 110 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 61 / 110 Meeting Timeline Walk-Through (Fast Track example) 1.CRA: Receives the initial TIF application and reviews it at a public meeting. If this application involves any resi- dential uses the CRA Director sends a letter to the Finance Director at GIPS. Prior to the application being presented to the CRA. JANUARY 09 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 62 / 110 2. Planning Commission: Reviews the application for land use and holds a public hearing. Taxing Entities Invited by Certified Mail and Public Hearing Notice Pub- lished 2 times at least 10 days prior to the meeting. This is a public meeting any member of the public may attend and speak. FEBRUARY 6 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 63 / 110 3. CRA: Reviews the findings from the Planning Commission. FEBRUARY 13 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 64 / 110 4. City Council/Village Board: Reviews findings from CRA and Planning Commission and decides whether to pro- ceed with project. FEBRUARY 26 Taxing Entities Invited by Certified Mail and Public Hearing Notice Pub- lished 2 times at least 10 days prior to the meeting. This is a public meeting any member of the public may attend and speak. If Council Approves the Redevelopment Plan , The Project is Eligible for TIF Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 65 / 110 5. CRA: Formalizes agreement with developer at public meeting. MARCH 9 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 66 / 110 After all the meeti ngs . . . The developer gets a TIF bond, which is used to secure private financing for the pro- ject. Project construction occurs. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 67 / 110 Year-end 2019: Developer pays the property taxes on the pre- improvement value as of Jan. 1, 2018. Taxes ($2,112) are dis- tributed to political subdivisions. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 68 / 110 Year-end 2020: Developer pays the property taxes on the post- improvement value as of Jan. 1 2019. Taxes ($2,112) are paid out to the political subdivisions. The $10,560 in new taxes on the improvement are paid to the CRA to pay for the bond. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 69 / 110 All TIF Projects January 7, 2019 CRA of Grand Island Approved Projected Projected 2018 Projected Value Project Contract Date Term Payoff***Value*Base TIF Excess Valuation vs. Actual Value TIF Amount Project Description 1 Yancey Hotel 2 GILI**12/15/1996 12/15/2011 $ 3,000,000 $ 9,561 $ 1,770,879 $548,333 60 units multifamily Low to Moderate income housing 3 GI Cherry Park, LTD. Two**12/15/1998 12/15/2013 $ 2,700,000 $ 9,942 $ 1,423,813 $479,799 60 units multifamily Low to Moderate income housing 4 RSF LTD PARTNERSHIP (Gentle Dental)**9/3/2002 12/31/2017 12/31/2017 $ 355,000 $ 168,849 $ 265,541 $ 434,390 $37,000 Remodel existing structure into dental office 5 PROCON (City Hall)9/1/2003 12/31/2018 12/31/2018 $ 1,063,000 $ 189,234 $ 1,227,538 $ 1,416,772 $162,967 Acquistion/Demotion and Renovation of Old City Hall 6 Walnut Housing, Inc 7/28/2004 12/31/2019 12/31/2019 $ 3,500,000 $ 107,150 $ 2,200,860 $ 2,308,010 $ (1,191,990)$668,000 88 Units of affordable housing and 1000 sq ft. of commercial office space 7 Bruns Pet Grooming 3/1/2006 12/31/2021 12/31/2018 $ 497,960 $ 61,959 $ 664,004 $ 725,963 $ 228,003 $133,533 Build a 4704 square foot building for pet boarding and grooming 8 Girard Vet Clinic 9/21/2006 12/31/2021 12/31/2021 $ 541,163 $ 78,431 $ 491,853 $ 570,284 $ 29,121 $142,500 Build a 4700 square foot building for a veterinary office 9 Southeast Crossings 11/15/2006 12/31/2021 12/31/2021 $ 786,353 $ 232,690 $ 729,399 $ 962,089 $ 175,736 $182,560 Incorporate an existing 1500 sq foot building into a 7,780 square foot commercial center 10 PROCON (Geddes St. Appts)10/18/2007 12/31/2022 12/31/2022 $ 1,400,000 $ 27,498 $ 1,471,256 $ 1,498,754 $ 98,754 $420,000 Build 5 four-plex handicapped accessible apartment buildings 11 South Pointe Development LLC 1/1/2009 12/31/2024 12/31/2024 $ 5,330,000 $ 234,722 $ 3,889,696 $ 4,124,418 $ (1,205,582)$1,564,409 Build 80+ room Hotel on South Locust 12 Todd Enck 1/1/2009 12/31/2024 6/30/2019 $ 300,000 $ 20,467 $ 290,472 $ 310,939 $ 10,939 $46,870 Build 2 Duplex Buildings at Blake and Darr 13 Casey's Store (Five Points)3/19/2009 12/31/2024 12/31/2024 $ 1,400,000 $ 172,713 $ 653,121 $ 825,834 $ (574,166)$383,459 Redevelop existing convenience store with new one at Five Points 14 John Schulte Contruction 3/2/2010 12/31/2025 12/31/2021 $ 293,582 $ 63,684 $ 361,019 $ 424,703 $ 131,121 $55,525 Build 4 unit apt. building at Anna and Lincoln Remove existing single family home 15 Pharmacy Properties, LLC 2/17/2010 12/31/2025 12/31/2021 $ 387,000 $ 39,495 $ 549,595 $ 589,090 $ 202,090 $111,000 Build Pharmacy on 4th street 16 Ken Ray, LLC 7/1/2010 12/21/2025 6/30/2020 $ 1,800,000 $ 856,619 $ 2,148,693 $ 3,005,312 $ 1,205,312 $299,600 Build 17,500 square feet of commercial/office space at Locust and Stolley 17 Poplar Street Water Project 4/21/2010 12/31/2025 12/31/2025 $ 1,415,071 $ 1,155,016 $ 626,310 $ 1,781,326 $ 366,255 $136,000 Install water main on Poplar Street between 9th and 12th Streets (CRA Funded) 18 Skagway**5/5/2011 12/31/2026 $ 4,864,666 $ 2,252,800 $ 908,937 $ 3,161,737 $ (1,702,929)$798,654 Redevelop existing grocery store at Five Points 19 Arnold Wenn 2/28/2012 12/21/2027 12/31/2027 $ 180,193 $ 19,523 $ 211,168 $ 230,691 $ 50,498 $46,950 Demolish Existing Structure and Build a Duplex at 13th Street and Huston 20 Token Properties LLC 12/15/2011 12/31/2027 12/31/2027 $ 150,316 $ 14,507 $ 132,112 $ 146,619 $ (3,697)$43,255 Demolish Existing Structure and Build a Duplex on north Ruby 21 Stratford Plaza LLC (Howard Johnsons)2/29/2012 12/31/2027 12/31/2027 $ 3,690,783 $ 2,095,733 $ 1,532,860 $ 3,628,593 $ (62,190)$524,520 Redevelop existing hotel, restaurant and conference center at S. Locust and U.S. Hwy 34 22 EIG Grand Island LLC 6/13/2012 12/31/2027 12/31/2027 $ 6,872,758 $ 4,126,165 $ 3,317,944 $ 7,444,109 $ 571,351 $898,350 Redevelop existing grocery on State Street into 4 tennant spaces 23 Baker Development 8/17/2012 12/31/2027 12/31/2025 $ 180,000 $ 20,909 $ 173,959 $ 194,868 $ 14,868 $42,000 Build a Duplex on two vacant lots purchase property and extend utilities 24 Token Properties LLC (Carey St)9/19/2012 12/31/2027 12/31/2025 $ 360,000 $ 38,645 $ 363,626 $ 402,271 $ 42,271 $78,000 Demolish existing structure and build 2 duplexes on site 25 Gordman Grand Island LLC 9/19/2012 12/31/2027 12/31/2027 $ 6,000,000 $ 2,187,305 $ 3,284,930 $ 5,472,235 $ (527,765)$1,072,785 Renovate existing commercial space on U.S. 281 26 Token Properties LLC (Kimball St)12/19/2012 12/31/2028 $ 160,000 $ 17,475 $ 127,642 $ 145,117 $ (14,883)$38,372 Acquistion and Demolition of exisitng house and replace with duplex 27 Auto One Inc.11/14/2012 12/31/2028 $ 480,000 $ 90,194 $ 646,954 $ 737,148 $ 257,148 $159,000 Build tri-plex on Pine St. and renovate commercial space Locust St. 28 Habitat (St Paul Road)11/19/2012 12/31/2028 $ 240,000 $ 46,851 $ 201,918 $ 248,769 $ 8,769 $66,000 Acquistion and Demolition of existing house and replace with 3 houses 29 Chief 5/29/2013 12/31/2028 $ 3,869,145 $ 2,183,323 $ 175,270 $ 2,358,593 $ (1,510,552)$579,870 Construction of an addition to the Chief Fabrication Plant on Adams St. 30 Copper Creek (The Guarantee Group)7/26/2013 12/31/2039 $ 31,500,000 $ -$ 2,912,195 $4,000,000 Construction of 200+ single family dwellings 2013 Base Year Houses 7/1/2014 12/31/2029 $ 134,194 $ 3,450,937 $ 3,585,131 $4,000,000 2014 Base Year Houses 7/1/2015 12/31/2030 $ 805,379 $ 13,168,759 $ 13,974,138 2015 Base Year Houses 7/1/2016 12/31/2031 $ 390,617 $ 12,363,714 $ 12,754,331 2016 Base Years Houses 7/1/2016 12/31/1932 $ 170,394 $ 3,928,201 $ 4,098,595 2017 Base Years Houses 7/1/2017 12/31/1933 $ 17,377 $ 34,412,195 31 Habitat (8th and Superior)4/24/2014 12/31/2029 $ 455,000 $ 14,125 $ 506,102 $ 520,227 $ 65,227 $123,000 Develop lots for and build 7 Habitat Homes 32 Mainstay Suites 4/16/2014 12/31/2029 $ 3,000,000 $ 263,105 $ 2,969,301 $ 3,232,406 $ 232,406 $479,685 Purchase Property, Install Utilities and Build an Extended Stay Hotel 33 Tower 217 6/24/2014 12/31/2029 $ 750,000 $ 99,655 $ 1,225,269 $ 1,324,924 $ 574,924 $236,000 Renovate an existing Downtown Building 34 Pridon LLC 5/7/2015 12/31/2030 $ 2,400,000 $ 1 $ 1,778,183 $ 1,778,184 $ (621,816)$330,000 Extend utilities to support veteran's housing 35 SMD-AWG Five Points 6/5/2015 12/31/2030 $ 7,858,000 $ 915,957 $ 5,662,281 $ 6,578,238 $ (1,279,762)$1,600,000 Purchase Property Building New Grocery Store, Extend Utiliies, Remove old Store 36 Grand Island Mall 10/30/2014 12/31/2030 $ 21,570,000 $ 2,044,858 $ 8,936,921 $ 10,981,779 $ (10,588,221)$5,600,000 Renovate existing commercial space on U.S. 281, Create additional outlots 37 TC Enck Builders, Inc (1616 S Eddy)6/10/2015 12/31/2030 $ 160,000 $ 9,460 $ 157,891 $ 167,351 $ 7,351 $38,000 Extend utilities and build duplex on vacant lot 38 T & S Development (312 W 3rd)11/2/2015 12/31/2030 $ 1,136,841 $ 353,827 $ 591,621 $ 945,448 $ (191,393)$272,788 Finish 2nd floor office space in downton building 39 Bosselman Real Estate (1616 S Locust)9/29/2015 12/31/2030 $ 22,778,988 $ 2,652,701 $ 4,184,187 $ 6,836,888 $ (15,942,100)$6,552,000 Renovate Existing Building and build hotel and office space 40 Hatchery Holdings, LLC 12/31/2031 $ 11,600,000 $ 123,002 $ 7,657,364 $ 7,780,366 $ (3,819,634)$2,675,913 Purchase Land, Extend Utilities, Site work, Engineering for Hatchery Operation Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 70 / 110 41 Pump & Pantry, Inc.5/9/2016 12/31/2031 $ 2,652,085 $ 393,355 $ 393,355 $748,688 Purchase Land, Extend Utilities, Site work, Engineering for Convenience Store 42 Wing Properties Inc.5/11/2016 12/31/2031 $ 382,266 $ 71,384 $ 128,938 $ 200,322 $ (181,944)$110,485 Renovate Existing Building for commercial and residential space 43 Talon Apartments 1/1/2017 12/31/2031 $ 19,484,580 $ 33,545 $ 3,470,617 $ 3,504,162 $ (15,980,418)$4,778,475 Develop 288 Apartments in 8 building on Vanosdal Ball Fields (first 72 units) Talon Apartments (2017 Units)1/1/2018 $ 10,800 $ 2,764,659 $ 2,775,459 $ 2,775,459 Second 72 Units 44 Hoppe Homes East Park on Stuhr 12/31/2031 $ 7,500,000 $ 166,178 $ 5,045,957 $ 5,212,135 $ (2,287,865)$1,495,000 Develop 80 apartment in 7 buildings east of Cherry Park Apts (GILI 1 and 2) 45 TW Ziller Labor Temple 12/31/2031 $ 721,747 $ 64,628 $ 46,515 $ 111,143 $ (610,604)$220,000 Develop 11 apartments in the Federation of Labor Temple Building Downtown 46 Middleton 9/24/2016 12/31/2031 $ 936,667 $ 886,524 $ 659,287 $ 1,545,811 $ 609,144 $247,561 Develop regional warehouse and remodel office space for Middleton Electric 47 Think Smart ( 204 N. Carey)3/15/2017 12/31/2032 12/31/2024 $ 519,140 $ 8,400 $ 86,816 $ 95,216 $ (423,924)$48,140 Develop empty lot into four-plex apartment 48 Peaceful Root (Brown Hotel 112 W. 2nd)3/15/2017 12/31/2032 $ 1,014,538 $ 140,447 $ 140,447 $ (874,091)$263,000 Develop former hotel into three apartments, yoga studio, retail space and parking garage 49 Weinrich Developments (523 E. Division)8/9/2017 12/31/2032 $ 300,000 $ 39,149 $ 65,255 $ 104,404 $ (195,596)$52,768 Demolish substandard single-family house and replace with four-plex apartment 50 Prataria Ventures (Hospital)9/26/2017 12/31/2032 $ 63,000,000 $ 381,000 $ 381,000 $ (62,619,000)$15,800,000 Build Hospital, Medical Office Building and Hotel 51 O'Neill Wood Resources 11/28/2017 12/31/2032 $ 1,140,993 $ 199,650 $ 199,650 $ (941,343)$209,000 Puchase property and construct Recycling Center 52 Hedde Building LLC (Hedde Building)**9/12/2018 12/31/2033 $ 1,952,402 $ 101,218 $ 101,218 $ (1,851,184)$603,425 Redevelop Downtown Building for Commmercial and Residential Uses 53 Urban Island LLC (320 N Pine)1/3/2018 12/31/2032 $ 654,361 $ 150,688 $ 150,688 $ (503,673)$164,181 Redevelop Downtown Building for Commmercial and Residential Uses 54 Take Flight Development (209 W 3rd)1/11/2018 12/31/2032 $ 414,889 $ 110,564 $ 110,564 $ (304,325)$99,200 Redevelop Downtown Building for Commmercial and Residential Uses 55 Personal Automotive** Mendex Enterprises Pending $ 4,396,629 $ 717,090 $ 717,090 $ (3,679,539)$886,695 Redevelop 4 Buildings for Commercial/Industrial Purposes 56 Weinrich Developments (408 E 2nd)$ 300,000 $ 8,712 $ 8,712 $ (291,288)$40,946 Acquire and clear property and build 3 Plex on a Vacant Lot 57 Copper Creek Phase 2 (The Guarantee Group)**6/13/2018 12/31/2040 $ 18,904,382 $ 504,382 $ 504,382 $ (18,400,000)$4,754,848 Develop 80 Single Family Homes over a period of up to 10 years Copper Creek Phase 2 2017 Lookback $ 20,417 $ 20,417 $ 20,417 58 Cenrtral NE Truck Wash Inc 8/8/2018 12/31/2033 $ -$ -$849,520 Aquire and clear property for a Truck Wash and Trailer Washout Facility 59 Grand Island Hotel LLC 11/14/2018 12/31/2033 $ -$1,824,179 Acquire propery install utilities and streets and build a 79 unit hotel 60 Paramount Development LLC (Sears 2nd Floor)12/12/2018 12/31/2034 $ 550,000 $ 77,000 $ 77,000 $159,814 Acquire propery and renovate the 2nd floor of the old Sears Building for 4 apartments 61 Orchard LLC/Hoppe Homes LP Pending $ 40,000,000 $ 203,000 $ 203,000 $6,000,000 To develop property and build 181 units of work force housing over an estimated 9 years 62 Paramount Development LLC (Sears 1st Floor)Pending $ 640,000 $ 52,000 $ 52,000 $199,000 Acquire property renovate part of the 1st floor of the old Sears Buidling for commericial and residential uses Wing Properties Inc. 112 E 3rd St Pending $105,085 Redevelopment downtown property for main floor commercial and upper floor residential Rawr Holding LLC. 110 w 2nd St Pending Redevelopment downtown property for main floor commercial and upper floor residential Amur Financial (Old Wells Fargo Buiding)Pending Projected 2018 Value*Base TIF Excess Valuation TIF Amount $301,954,872 $25,805,152 $98,235,690 $155,262,489 $72,061,289 * Amount Developer agreed not to protest in contract with CRA ** TIF Contract Completed Mixed Use (Commercial and Housing) *** If project payoff is prior to contract end this project should pay off faster than expected Housing Note projects listed as pending may be in process Commercial/Industrial Development Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 71 / 110 18 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 72 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 1 Introduction The Community Redevelopment Authority (CRA) is tasked with taking action in specified areas of the community to remove, prevent or inhibit physical deterioration (blighted and substandard conditions) that will result in lower property values and create disincentives to private investment. One of the major components of this is utilizing Tax Increment Financing (TIF) for developments through blighted and substandard areas within the community. The purpose of this survey is to better understand how Tax Increment Financing is used within different communities across the state of Nebraska varying in size. From that, the findings are intended to be used to help educate the general population in the City of Grand Island of TIF usage and how it is established in each project. Background Tax Increment Financing was established in the early 1950s in the state of California. Originally TIF was used to generate money for development to secure federal aid for projects. Over the years the usage of TIF has expanded in such a way that municipalities can encourage development within their respective communities1. To date 49 of 50 states allows the use of TIF. Each state that allows TIF has developed legislation based on its needs. Nebraska voters approved the use of Tax Increment Financing in 1978, with legislation being passed in 1979 by the State Legislature to allow Tax Increment Financing for developments. TIF was introduced to the City of Grand Island with a major redevelopment of the Yancey Hotel in the mid-1980s. To date the City of Grand Island has approved 60 TIF projects (Commercial, Residential, Mix-use) with the utilization of Tax Increment Financing2. Tax Increment Financing (TIF) in Nebraska Tax Increment Financing in Nebraska is used to fund the cost of infrastructure associated with new developments located in designated blighted and substandard areas. Community redevelopment laws were put in place to allow for the financing of TIF projects to occur from the increased property tax generated by the improvements of the project. The City of Grand Island has established a Community Redevelopment Authority (CRA) to oversee redevelopment projects within city limits. Tax Increment Financing process The process of TIF is established when an area within city limits is declared blighted and substandard. Areas throughout a community can be determined blighted if the following criteria are met: •has a substantial number of deteriorated or deteriorating structures, •has defective or inadequate street layout, 1 Tax-Increment Financing: The Need for Increased Transparency and Accountability in Local Economic Development Subsidies. Retrieved December 10, 2018 from https://www.smartgrowthamerica.org/app/legacy/documents/Tax-Increment-Financing.pdf 2 The Use of Tax Increment Financing in Nebraska. Retrieved December 6, 2018 from https://www.platteinstitute.org/Library/docLib/20130710_my_Platte-TIF.pdf Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 73 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 2 •has a faulty lot layout in relation to size, adequacy, accessibility, or usefulness, •has insanitary or unsafe conditions, •deterioration of site or other improvements, •has diversity of ownership, •has tax or special assessment delinquency exceeding the fair value of the land, •has defective or unusual conditions of title, •has improper subdivision or obsolete platting, •the existence of conditions which endanger life or property by fire and other causes, •factors that’s substantially impairs or arrests the sound growth of the community, hinders the provision of housing accommodations, or constitutes an economic or social liability •is detrimental to the public health, safety, morals, or welfare in its present condition and •has at least one of the following conditions: Unemployment in the designated area is at least one hundred twenty percent of the state or national average; the average age of the residential or commercial units in the area is at least forty years; more than half of the plotted and subdivided property in an area is unimproved land that has been within the city for forty years and has remained unimproved during that time; the per capita income of the area is lower than the average per capita income of the city or village in which the area is designated; or the area has had either stable or decreasing population based on the last two decennial censuses. A community can be considered substandard if the following criteria are met: •has a predominance of buildings that are: dilapidated, deteriorated, age or obsolescence, inadequate provision for ventilation, light, air, sanitation, or open spaces, •has a high density of population and overcrowding, •has the existence of conditions which endanger life or property by fire and other causes, •has a combination of factors, that are conducive to ill health, transmission of disease, infant mortality, juvenile delinquency, and crime, •is detrimental to the public health, safety, morals, or welfare” 3. Once a redevelopment plan is submitted and approved for projects in the designated area, a redevelopment contract can be approved for eligible expenses. Eligible expenses include the acquisition of land, site preparation, demolition, public improvements and any planning cost associated with the TIF application. Communities are allowed to "capture" the property tax on the increased valuation of property created by approved, eligible redevelopment projects. This "captured" tax increment then is used to pay off the TIF bond. The base property valuation will then continue to be paid to all taxing 3 Nebraska Revised Statute 18-2103. Retrieved December 6, 2018 from https://nebraskalegislature.gov/laws/statutes.php?statute=18-2103 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 74 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 3 entities. TIF projects must not exceed a 15 year period. See Appendix A for an example of how TIF works. Requirements for TIF include, but are not limited to: The project is applicable to real property only; The property must be within the corporate boundaries of the city (cities of the 2nd class and villages)4; however, the city may annex noncontiguous land to develop agricultural processing facilities that will become a TIF project; The division of tax for TIF may not exceed 15 years; The taxes attributable to the excess value can only be used for the repayment of the debt related to the project; and The city/CRA must provide written notice to both the county assessor and county treasurer to cease the division of tax when the debt on the project is paid in full5. Methodology and Selection Criteria The Hall County and Regional Planning department decided to use the following criteria to review similarities and differences on Tax Increment Financing among Nebraska communities, as shown below: •Survey three or more communities •Cities/ towns located in the state of Nebraska •Total population above 10,000 Five communities, shown in Figure 1, were selected to be surveyed: Scottsbluff, Nebraska Hastings, Nebraska Kearney, Nebraska Norfolk, Nebraska Lincoln, Nebraska 4 Nebraska Revised Statute 17-405.01. Retrieved January 3, 2018 from https://nebraskalegislature.gov/laws/statutes.php?statute=17-405.01 5 Report to the Legislature Nebraska Department of Revenue Property Assessment Division Retrieved December 10, 2018 from http://www.revenue.nebraska.gov/PAD/research/TIF_Reports/TIF_REPORT_2016.pdf Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 75 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 4 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 76 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 5 Community Questionnaire Once the selection process was completed each community was contacted via telephone to take part in the community questionnaire. Survey questionnaires were distributed via email to each community’s representative with two weeks to complete. See appendix B for full responses provided by each community. Tax Increment Financing Survey 1.How long are the TIF bonds being written for? Four of five communities (Scottsbluff, Hastings, Norfolk, and Lincoln) indicated that TIF bonds were written for 15 years. The City of Norfolk explained, phased projects may extend the length of the bonds. Kearney noted that bonds are not issued for TIF projects. 2.Which types of projects within the community utilize Tax Increment Financing (TIF) the most? Two of five cities (Hastings, Norfolk) explained that residential projects utilize Tax Increment Financing the most within their community. The Cities of Kearney and Lincoln indicated that commercial development projects are the top user of TIF in their respective community. 3.What types of documentation is needed by developers to acquire Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds? Scottsbluff We have an application form they need to complete, a blight study has to be performed, a cost benefit analysis, redevelopment plan, applicant must show the financial ability to complete the project. Hastings An application is required and must include; A detailed project description, A development financing plan, including the sources of funds and loan terms. A preliminary commitment for financing. A statement and demonstration that the project would not proceed without CRA assistance. A proforma statement indicating the projected costs and revenues. A detailed pro-forma identifying pre-TIF rate of return and gap in project financing. Submit detailed pro-forma identifying project-plus-TIF rate of return and financial structure. Preliminary plans for the project. A list of public improvements to be constructed in conjunction with the project. Evidence that the project meets the evaluation criteria. A project development schedule. Kearney Site Development Plan, Project Budget with TIF eligible costs, Cost-Benefit Analysis from the County Assessor. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 77 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 6 Norfolk The standard documentation of redevelopment plan and agreement that states “but-for” TIF the project wouldn’t be feasible. Cost-benefit analysis. Return on investment calculations both with and without TIF. Lincoln When first approaching the City, generally a project description, site plan and pro-forma. Schematics and renderings are included in the Redevelopment Agreement and must be strictly adhered to. Changes must be approved in advance. After a Redevelopment Agreement is approved by City Council, proof of financial ability must be provided and approved by the City’s Finance Director. This is often in the form of a letter from the financial institution funding the project. 4.Are developers required to show documents of various BIDs on the project? Three of the cities (Kearney, Norfolk, Lincoln) surveyed indicated that developers are not required to show documents pertaining to bids placed on projects utilizing TIF. It is important to note that within the City of Lincoln, if the TIF project includes public improvements, developers are required to show bids along with work alongside the City’s Purchasing Office following city’s guidelines. The City of Scottsbluff noted that upon request developers are asked to show bids within the scope of the project. 5.Does your municipality have a limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? If yes, what is the limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? All cities indicated that there is no limit to the amount of TIF projects being issued per year. 6.Does your municipality have a competitive application process or is the application process based on the order applicants submits’ their application? Please add additional information if possible. Scottsbluff The applications would be reviewed in the order they are received but there aren’t that many that “competition” is created usually. The applications are considered based on the location of the project and whether it is within a blighted and substandard area, the economic feasibility of the project and whether or not the project meets the main principals set form by the City’s comprehensive plan. Hastings There is no competitive application process on TIF projects unless the property is owned or controlled by the CRA/City. If the CRA owns/controls the property it will advertise for RFP’s to purchase and rehabilitate the property. Kearney Application process is not competitive. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 78 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 7 Norfolk The process begins when the applicant submits a complete and approvable redevelopment plan. Lincoln No, we do not have an application process. Developers approach the Urban Development Department (we are the City’s designated Redevelopment Authority). 7.Does your municipality have an amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body to be used per year for TIF projects? If yes, what is the amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body? All cities indicated that there is no set amount of funds allocated of TIF projects being used per year. 8.Does your municipality have a cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project? If yes, what is the amount of TIF funds per project? All cities indicated that there is no cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project. However Scottsbluff explained that there is a minimum of $50,000 in TIF eligible costs required for projects to be considered by the Council 9.Does your municipality have a processing and/or administrative fee? If yes, please provide the fee/ cost amounts. Scottsbluff The fee structure for TIF projects are as follows: 1.An initial application fee of $250.00 – due upon submission of the TIF application 2.Upon conceptual approval of TIF application by the CRA, a processing fee based on the schedule below shall be remitted if the applicant wishes a Plan to be created and considered by the Planning Commission, CRA, and City Council. The processing fee is intended to cover the City’s costs and expenses in creating and/or reviewing the Plan and running the Plan through the appropriate approval process. The processing fee shall be paid prior to the City’s preparation and/or review of the Plan. If the processing fee has not been paid for a period of six (6) months after notification of conceptual approval, the application shall be deemed abandoned and the application fee forfeited. The processing fee schedule is as follows: If the estimated TIF proceeds available for the Project are $50,000.00 to $75,000.00, the processing fee shall be equal to 5% of the estimated TIF proceeds, and the processing fee will also cover the administrative fee. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 79 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 8 If the estimated TIF proceeds available for the Project are $75,000.01 to $100,000.00, the processing fee shall be equal to 8% of the estimated TIF proceeds, and the processing fee will also cover the administrative fee. If the estimated TIF proceeds available for the Project are over $100,000.00, the processing fee shall be the greater of (a) $5,000.00 or (b) 1% of the estimated TIF proceeds. This processing fee will be in addition to the administrative fee set forth below. Upon approval of the Redevelopment Plan and Redevelopment Agreement, the person or organization receiving the TIF Proceeds estimated to be over $100,000.00 shall pay an administrative fee of $5,000. The administrative fee is intended to cover the City’s costs and expenses of administering the TIF bond during its life. Below are examples of the Fees due to the City for particular projects: Estimated TIF Proceeds Application Fee Processing Fee Administrative Fee Total $50,000.00 $250.00 $2,500.00 (5%) Included in Processing Fee $2,750.00 $75,000.00 $250.00 $3,750.00 (5%) Included in Processing Fee $4,000.00 $80,000.00 $250.00 $6,400.00 (8%) Included in Processing Fee $6,650.00 Estimated TIF Proceeds Application Fee Processing Fee Administrative Fee Total $100,000.00 $250.00 $8,000.00 (8%) Included in Processing Fee $8,250.00 $110,000.00 $250.00 $5,000.00 (minimum) $5,000.00 $10,250.00 $350,000.00 $250.00 $5,000.00 (minimum) $5,000.00 $10,250.00 $500,000.00 $250.00 $5,000.00 (1%) $5,000.00 $10,250.00 $600,000.00 $250.00 $6,000.00 (1%) $5,000.00 $11,250.00 $1,000,000.00 $250.00 $10,000.00 (1%) $5,000.00 $15,250.00 Hastings The Hastings CRA recently added a non-refundable $300 fee for TIF applications and if the project is approved an administrative fee of $1,500 is charged. This is payable to the CRA. These costs are TIF eligible expenditures. In addition the City of Hastings charges a $450 administrative fee for modification of the Area Redevelopment Plan. Kearney No Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 80 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 9 Norfolk No, except to be reimbursed for the cost of noticing and from the TIF dollars, reimbursement for our TIF attorney. The cost of blight and substandard studies are also charged to the Redeveloper if done specifically for their project. Lincoln Yes. Our fee is 1.5% of the first $2 million of TIF then 1.5% in excess of $2 million. Fees go into the general fund. We have a biennial City budget. At the end of the budget period, anything over $200,000 goes into a fund for affordable housing. This is relatively new and we just finished the first biennial budget where this has been in place. It generated about $175,000 for affordable housing. 10.Does your municipality’s Community Redevelopment Authority try to attract specific redevelopment projects through advertisement within the community? If yes, what types of projects are being requested? Three of the cities (Scottsbluff, Kearney, Norfolk,) surveyed stated that the Community Redevelopment Authority does not solicit specific redevelopment projects through advertisement within the community. The City of Hastings indicated that its CRA advertises requests proposals for redevelopment on the properties that it owns or controls and the project type depends upon the type of property. The City of Lincoln showed does not usually advertise for redevelopment projects, but issues a Request for Redevelopment Proposals (IFRP). IFRP are open-ended and requests that developers bring in projects/ redevelopment plans to consider. Projects are usually not specific in type but occasionally an RFP will be issued for a specific type of project. Review Findings The community review compares Tax Increment Financing in Grand Island, Nebraska with other communities around the state based on TIF laws. This section is to assess the usage of TIF among each community surveyed in comparison to how the City of Grand Island uses Tax Increment Financing. There were similarities found from each city surveyed as to how TIF is being used in the City of Grand Island. Grand Island just like the majority of communities surveyed writes TIF bonds for the full 15 years legally allowed by states statue. Other similarities includes no requirements for bid documents, no limit on the amount of TIF projects per year, no limit on the amount of TIF projects, no cap amount of funds allocated for TIF projects by the governing body, no cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project, and lastly the CRA does not attempt to attract redevelopment projects through advertisement. It was also found, that though communities documentation varies in the needed information to apply for TIF; overall communities require proof of adequate funding for the project, a cost-benefit analysis, and a redevelopment plan. All consistent with what the City of Grand Island asks of Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 81 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 10 developers. The application process was also similar among most communities as they are processed in the order they are received. The City of Lincoln does not have an application process, developers inquire about possible developments to the City’s designated Redevelopment Authority (Urban Development Department). It is important to note that the CRA in Hastings allows for a competitive application process on TIF projects only when the property is owned or controlled by the CRA/City. It is also important to acknowledge that while Grand Island does charge a process/ administrative fee; likewise all communities surveyed except for the City of Kearney and Norfolk has a fee. However, the City of Norfolk does not charge a processing/ administrative fee but requires the developers to reimburse the City for the cost of notifying taxing entities and from the TIF dollars, reimbursement for utilizing the City’s TIF attorney. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 82 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 11 Appendix A: Quick and Brief Description of TIF Tax Increment Financing (TIF) Quick and Brief Description of TIF Redevelopment site is worth $100,000 before redevelopment and has taxes annually of $2000. Developer makes $1,000,000 investment in property. Property is now worth $1,100,000. Annual taxes are $22,000. City (CRA) captures increment of $20,000 ($22,000 minus $2,000) to be used for eligible activities for a period of up to 15 years $300,000 maximum. CRA can issue TIF Bonds (bonds can be, but do not have to be guaranteed by the full faith and credit of the municipality) to generate the money at the front end of the project or CRA can borrow money secured by the TIF revenues or Developer can borrow money secured by the TIF revenues. Without the investment and creation of the additional value there is no increment to generate revenue. Improvements to a building such as a new roof or windows or paint are unlikely to generate a substantial increment in valuation. But For……… TIF is subject to the “But For” clause. That is “But For” TIF this project would not happen. The “But For” clause does not mean that companies like Wal-Mart, Target, McDonalds or any other large company with strong financial backing are not eligible for TIF. “But For” is a measure of financial backing that encourages more and better investment in areas that might have trouble attracting that investment. It is not simply a measure of the financial backing of a project. “But For” this financing: a company might choose to build in another part of town or another town; or might choose to build a smaller or less expensive facility; or might choose not to build at this time; or might choose not to build at all. If TIF were used only when financing was the single limiting factor (“But For having financing”) it would be available just to those projects that have a high chance of financial failure. What can you pay for with Tax Increment Financing? TIF can be used to pay for a variety of public improvements including: Streets, Sewer, Water, Drainage (storm sewer), utility upgrades, trails, parks, landscaping, public parking. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 83 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 12 TIF can be used to pay for a variety of private improvements including: Property acquisition, demolition, renovation, site preparation, studies, plans, engineering, and architecture Activities with costs that can be incurred prior to approval include: Preparation of materials and applications; preparation of cost-benefit analysis; preparation of redevelopment contract; preparation of bond/financing instruments; land acquisition and related diligence; and site demolition and preparation. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 84 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 13 Appendix B: Community Survey Tax Increment Financing Survey City of Scottsbluff, NE 1.How long are the TIF bonds being written for? Up to 15 years 2.Which types of projects within the community utilize Tax Increment Financing (TIF) the most? Public improvements, land acquisition costs, site preparation, utility extensions, rehabilitation, renovation, public parking 3.What types of documentation is needed by developers to acquire Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds? We have an application form they need to complete, a blight study has to be performed, a cost benefit analysis, redevelopment plan, applicant must show the financial ability to complete the project 4.Are developers required to show documents of various BIDs on the project? Upon request 5.Does your municipality have a limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? If yes, what is the limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? No limit, projects and applications reviewed on a case by case basis as they are received 6.Does your municipality have a competitive application process or is the application process based on the order applicants submits’ their application? Please add additional information if possible. The applications would be reviewed in the order they are received but there aren’t that many that “competition” is created usually. The applications are considered based on the location of the project and whether it is within a blighted and substandard area, the economic feasibility of the project and whether or not the project meets the main principals set form by the City’s comprehensive plan. 7.Does your municipality have an amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body to be used per year for TIF projects? If yes, what is the amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body? Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 85 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 14 No set allocation of funds 8.Does your municipality have a cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project? If yes, what is the amount of TIF funds per project? No cap but there is a minimum of $50,000 in TIF eligible costs required for the project to be considered by the Council 9.Does your municipality have a processing and/or administrative fee? If yes, please provide the fee/ cost amounts. See attached schedule included in TIF Application (Appendix C) 10.Does your municipality’s Community Redevelopment Authority try to attract specific redevelopment projects through advertisement within the community? If yes, what types of projects are being requested? To date CRA has not done any advertising Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 86 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 15 Tax Increment Financing Survey City of Hastings CRA 1.How long are the TIF bonds being written for? Typically, the bonds are written for 15 years and some are paid off early. 2.Which types of projects within the community utilize Tax Increment Financing (TIF) the most? Housing – 35% Commercial/Retail/Office – 30% Industry – 14% Downtown Mixed Use – 14% Lodging – 7% 3.What types of documentation is needed by developers to acquire Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds? – An application is required and must include; A detailed project description, A development financing plan, including the sources of funds and loan terms. A preliminary commitment for financing. A statement and demonstration that the project would not proceed without CRA assistance. A proforma statement indicating the projected costs and revenues. A detailed pro-forma identifying pre-TIF rate of return and gap in project financing. Submit detailed pro-forma identifying project-plus-TIF rate of return and financial structure. Preliminary plans for the project. A list of public improvements to be constructed in conjunction with the project. Evidence that the project meets the evaluation criteria. A project development schedule. 4.Are developers required to show documents of various BIDs on the project? Developers may be required to show bids on the project depending upon the improvements. Developers are required to provide copies of paid bills for TIF eligible costs. 5.Does your municipality have a limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? If yes, what is the limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? Currently there is no limit on the number of TIF projects issued per year. 6.Does your municipality have a competitive application process or is the application process based on the order applicants submits’ their application? Please add additional information if possible. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 87 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 16 There is no competitive application process on TIF projects unless the property is owned or controlled by the CRA/City. If the CRA owns/controls the property it will advertise for RFP’s to purchase and rehabilitate the property. The RFP includes a statement of purpose and the proposal must include the following; DEVELOPER – Indicate the name and phone number of the proposed owner of the project. Provide the names of any others that will be involved in ownership of the project. OVERVIEW OF THE PROPOSAL – Present a statement that provides a clear identification of the proposal and indicates a clear understanding of the desired results. If the proposal deviates from the desired goals and objectives presented in the Statement of Purpose section, explain the reasons for the deviation. PRICE – Price to be paid for the real estate. PREVIOUS EXPERIENCE / QUALIFICATIONS – Present a listing of other previously completed projects. Provide the name and location of each project and provide any details that you feel would assist the Authority in their decision. PROJECT AND FINANCIAL REFERENCES – Provide the names, addresses, phone numbers and positions of your bank reference. Include any project references for other projects completed. DETAILED PLAN OF ACTION – Provide a detailed overview of how the proposal will be implemented. Include a step by step plan for all the elements of the project. Include a time schedule for completion of each element and a cost estimate for each element. Provide a site plan and floor plan for all proposed construction. FINANCING OF PROJECT – Describe how the proposal will be financed. Identify the sources of funds and the amounts from each source. Provide evidence of funding commitment, if available. IMPACT OF PROPOSAL – Describe the probable economic impact of the proposal, including; the number of construction and permanent jobs to be created; tax revenue to be created by the project; local firms to be utilized in the project; and any regional economic impact of the proposal. MANAGEMENT PLAN – Present a detailed management plan for the implementation and operation of the finished project. Describe how the project will be promoted and marketed. Identify the individuals and or firms responsible for each element of the plan. The Community Redevelopment Authority reserves the right to reject any or all proposals received or to negotiate in any manner necessary to accomplish the goals of the Authority. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 88 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 17 7.Does your municipality have an amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body to be used per year for TIF projects? If yes, what is the amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body? Currently there is no cap on TIF projects. 8.Does your municipality have a cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project? If yes, what is the amount of TIF funds per project? Currently there is no cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project. 9.Does your municipality have a processing and/or administrative fee? If yes, please provide the fee/ cost amounts. The Hastings CRA recently added a non-refundable $300 fee for TIF applications and if the project is approved an administrative fee of $1,500 is charged. This is payable to the CRA. These costs are TIF eligible expenditures. In addition the City of Hastings charges a $450 administrative fee for modification of the Area Redevelopment Plan. 10.Does your municipality’s Community Redevelopment Authority try to attract specific redevelopment projects through advertisement within the community? If yes, what types of projects are being requested? Currently the Hastings CRA advertises for proposals for redevelopment on the properties that it owns or controls. The project type depends upon the type of property. The CRA owns vacant lots usually residential in nature and commercial or mixed use properties. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 89 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 18 Tax Increment Financing Survey City of Kearney, NE 1.How long are the TIF bonds being written for? The City of Kearney does not issues bonds for TIF projects! 2.Which types of projects within the community utilize Tax Increment Financing (TIF) the most? Small to midsized commercial projects 3.What types of documentation is needed by developers to acquire Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds? Site Development Plan Project Budget with TIF eligible costs Cost Benefit Analysis from the County Assessor 4.Are developers required to show documents of various BIDs on the project? BID’s are not traditionally part of TIF projects within the City of Kearney. 5.Does your municipality have a limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? If yes, what is the limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? No 6.Does your municipality have a competitive application process or is the application process based on the order applicants submits’ their application? Please add additional information if possible. Application process is not competitive. 7.Does your municipality have an amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body to be used per year for TIF projects? If yes, what is the amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body? No 8.Does your municipality have a cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project? If yes, what is the amount of TIF funds per project? No Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 90 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 19 9.Does your municipality have a processing and/or administrative fee? If yes, please provide the fee/ cost amounts. No 10.Does your municipality’s Community Redevelopment Authority try to attract specific redevelopment projects through advertisement within the community? If yes, what types of projects are being requested? No Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 91 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 20 Tax Increment Financing Survey City of Norfolk, NE 1.How long are the TIF bonds being written for? Generally they are written for the full 15 years, but if the project is phased then the bonds for the project as a whole may go beyond 15 years. 2.Which types of projects within the community utilize Tax Increment Financing (TIF) the most? In the last year or so, a majority of the TIF projects have been residential. 3. What types of documentation is needed by developers to acquire Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds? The standard documentation of redevelopment plan and agreement that states “but-for” TIF the project wouldn’t be feasible. Cost benefit analysis. Return on investment calculations both with and without TIF. 4. Are developers required to show documents of various BIDs on the project? No. 5. Does your municipality have a limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? If yes, what is the limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? No. 6. Does your municipality have a competitive application process or is the application process based on the order applicants submits’ their application? Please add additional information if possible. The process begins when the applicant submits a complete and approvable redevelopment plan. 7. Does your municipality have an amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body to be used per year for TIF projects? If yes, what is the amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body? No. 8. Does your municipality have a cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project? If yes, what is the amount of TIF funds per project? No. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 92 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 21 9. Does your municipality have a processing and/or administrative fee? If yes, please provide the fee/ cost amounts. No, except to be reimbursed for the cost of noticing and from the TIF dollars, reimbursement for our TIF attorney. The cost of blight and substandard studies are also charged to the Redeveloper if done specifically for their project. 10. Does your municipality’s Community Redevelopment Authority try to attract specific redevelopment projects through advertisement within the community? If yes, what types of projects are being requested? No. Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 93 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 22 Tax Increment Financing Survey City of Lincoln, Nebraska Prepared by Wynn Hjermstad, AICP Community Development Manager Urban Development Department 402-441-8211; whjermstad@lincoln.ne.gov 1.How long are the TIF bonds being written for? 15 years 2.Which types of projects within the community utilize Tax Increment Financing (TIF) the most? Commercial, multi-family, mixed use. Some typical projects recently completed or underway now include: HUDL corporate headquarters, Haymarket District: private investment $30,000,000, TIF $6,000,000 (complete). Residential, Haymarket District: 18 market rate residential condos. Private investment $7,232,126; TIF $1,179,671 (under construction). Lied Place, downtown: 40 units luxury condos: private investment $25,000,000; TIF $5,000,000 (Plan amendment to City Council this month, Redevelopment Agreement currently being negotiated). Viet Hao ethnic grocery store and office, Antelope Valley area near downtown: private investment $1,716,000; TIF $128,200 (construction starting this month). Volleyball/Basketball sports facility, West O Street: 95,000 square feet; private investment $10,000,000; TIF $1,300,000 (Redevelopment agreement being negotiated). Mixed use office/residential, Havelock area: 5,000 square foot office, 4 market rate apartments. Private investment $1,090,000; TIF $110,000 (complete). Telegraph District Phase 2, Antelope Valley area near downtown: rehab and new construction, office, restaurants, @225 market rate apartments. Private investment $62,000,000, TIF $8,907,652 (under construction). Nebraska Innovation Campus Phase 2: 80,000 square foot office building. Private investment $15,300,000; TIF $3,116,291 (complete). 3.What types of documentation is needed by developers to acquire Tax Increment Financing (TIF) funds? When first approaching the City, generally a project description, site plan and pro-forma. Schematics and renderings are included in the Redevelopment Agreement and must be strictly adhered to. Changes must be approved in advance. After a Redevelopment Agreement is Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 94 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 23 approved by City Council, proof of financial ability must be provided and approved by the City’s Finance Director. This is often in the form of a letter from the financial institution funding the project. 4.Are developers required to show documents of various BIDs on the project? For private improvements, no, for public improvements, yes. Our preference is that they go through the City’s Purchasing Office but if they choose to bid themselves, they must follow the City’s process. We have prepared a Guide for developer’s use that I will attach. 5.Does your municipality have a limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? If yes, what is the limit on the amount of TIF projects being issued per year? No. Our guide is the percent of the City that can be declared blighted and substandard which, by state statute, is 35%. Lincoln is at about 12%. 6.Does your municipality have a competitive application process or is the application process based on the order applicants submits’ their application? Please add additional information if possible. No, we do not have an application process. Developers approach the Urban Development Department (we are the City’s designated Redevelopment Authority). Staff does a preliminary review, will review with other relevant City Departments (usually Planning and Public Works, may also include Building & Safety, Health, Parks & Rec depending on the project), then it is taken to the Mayor for approval to go forward. We then usually set up weekly meetings with the developer team and City staff to negotiate the Redevelopment Agreement. Everything is approved by the Mayor. We have weekly Redevelopment Project meetings with the Mayor to go over projects. 7.Does your municipality have an amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body to be used per year for TIF projects? If yes, what is the amount of funds per year allocated as a cap by the governing body? No. 8.Does your municipality have a cap on the amount of TIF funds used per project? If yes, what is the amount of TIF funds per project? No. 9.Does your municipality have a processing and/or administrative fee? If yes, please provide the fee/ cost amounts. Yes. Our fee is 1.5% of the first $2 million of TIF then 1.5% in excess of $2 million. Fees go into the general fund. We have a biennial City budget. At the end of the budget period, anything over $200,000 goes into a fund for affordable housing. This is relatively new and we just finished the Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 95 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 24 first biennial budget where this has been in place. It generated about $175,000 for affordable housing. 10.Does your municipality’s Community Redevelopment Authority try to attract specific redevelopment projects through advertisement within the community? If yes, what types of projects are being requested? Not usually. We generally issue a Request for Redevelopment Proposals (IFRP) and it is usually open-ended. Basically an IFRP says bring us projects to consider but does not usually get specific as to the type of project. Occasionally we will issue and RFP for a specific type of project. A final comment about TIF usage in Lincoln: we have done some affordable housing projects, mostly housing for first time homebuyers. We have done a few in partnership with Low Income Housing Tax Credit projects. The lack of affordable quality housing is becoming a significant issue in Lincoln, particularly for low income rental. We are currently exploring the issue of affordable housing in general in Lincoln and use of TIF for that purpose. Attached is a Guide for the bidding process (discussed in question 4, above). Here is a link to a general policy statement about use of TIF that is on our website: https://lincoln.ne.gov/city/urban/redev/pdf/tifpolicy.pdf Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 96 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 25 Appendix C: City of Scottsbluff Tax Increment Financing (TIF) Guidelines and Application Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 97 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 26 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 98 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 27 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 99 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 28 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 100 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 29 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 101 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 30 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 102 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 31 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 103 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 32 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 104 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 33 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 105 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 34 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 106 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 35 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 107 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 36 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 108 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 37 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 109 / 110 Tax Increment Financing Assessment The Regional Planning Commission of Hall County 38 Grand Island Study Session - 1/15/2019 Page 110 / 110