12/18/2012 Minutes CITY OF GRAND ISLAND, NEBRASKA
MINUTES OF CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING
December 18, 2012
Pursuant to due call and notice thereof, a Regular Meeting of the City Council of the City of
Grand Island, Nebraska was conducted in the Council Chambers of City Hall, 100 East First
Street, on December 18, 2012. Notice of the meeting was given in The Grand Island Independent
on December 12, 2012.
Mayor Jay Vavricek called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. The following City Council
members were present: Bob Niemann, Linna Dee Donaldson, Julie Hehnke, Mitch Nickerson,
Peg Gilbert, John Gericke, Scott Dugan, Mike Paulick, and Vaughn Minton. Councilmember
Chuck Haase was absent. The following City Officials were present: City Administrator Mary
Lou Brown, City Clerk RaNae Edwards, City Attorney Robert Sivick, Interim Public Works
Director Terry Brown and Finance Director Jaye Monter.
INVOCATION was given by Pastor Stan Davis, New Life Community Church, 301 West 2nd
Street followed by the PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE.
Mayor Vavricek introduced Community Youth Council member Stephanie Chandler.
PRESENTATIONS AND PROCLAMATIONS:
Presentation by the Barbershop Harmony Quartet with a Celebration of the Holidays. The
Barbershop Harmony Quartet sang several holiday songs.
Presentation of the "Mayor's Builder Award" to Bennett Chamness. Mayor Vavricek and
Council President Niemann presented the "Mayor's Builder Award"to Bennett Chamness for his
tireless efforts in supporting our troops with "Wear Red on Fridays". Mr. Chamness was present
for the recognition.
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
Public Hearing on Request from Bocho's, Inc. dba San Pedro's Mexican Restaurant, 2418 N.
Webb Road, Suite A for a Class "I" Liquor License. City Clerk RaNae Edwards reported that an
application for a Class "I" Liquor License had been received from Bocho's, Inc. dba San Pedro's
Mexican Restaurant, 2418 N. Webb Road, Suite A. Ms. Edwards presented the following
exhibits for the record: application submitted to the Liquor Control Commission and received by
the City on November 30, 2012; notice to the general public of date, time, and place of hearing
published on December 8, 2012; notice to the applicant of date, time, and place of hearing
mailed on November 30, 2012; along with Chapter 4 of the City Code. Staff recommended
denial based on the Police Department report under the Nebraska Liquor Control Act (Part II
Chapter 2 Section 010.01) for a false application. Nathan Bruner, 3423 2nd Avenue, Kearney, NE
requested the City Council send a "no recommendation" to the NLCC. No further public
testimony was heard.
Public Hearing on Acquisition of Utility Easement located in the 3800 Block of East Highway
34 (Charles & Laura Bosselman). Utilities Director Tim Luchsinger reported that acquisition of a
Page 2,City Council Regular Meeting,December 18,2012
utility easement located in the 3800 Block of East Highway 34 was needed in order to have
access to install, upgrade, maintain, and repair power appurtenances, including lines and
transformers for the purpose of placing underground conduit, primary power cable and a pad-
mounted transformer to provide electrical service to a new home. Staff recommended approval.
No public testimony was heard.
CONSENT AGENDA: Agenda item G-16 was removed from the agenda at the request of the
Finance Director. Motion by Donaldson, second by Dugan to approve the Consent Agenda
excluding item G-16. Upon roll call vote, all voted aye. Motion adopted.
Approving Corrections to the Minutes of February 28, 2012 City Council Regular Meeting.
Approving Minutes of December 4, 2012 City Council Regular Meeting.
Approving Minutes of December 11, 2012 City Council Study Session.
Approving Re-Appointments to the Electrical Board.
Approving Re-A•pointments to the Mechanical Examining Board.
Approving Re-Appointments to the Plumbers Examining Board.
#2012-355 — Approving Purchase of Mobile Field reporting forms and Field Interview Software
with Spillman Technologies Inc. of Salt Lake City, Utah in an Amount of$46,443.00.
#2012-356 — Approving Acquisition of Utility Easement located in the 3800 Block of East
Highway 34 (Charles and Laura Bosselman).
#2012-357 — Approving Bid Award for Tree Trimming Contract 2013-TT-1 with Tom's Tree
Service of Grand Island, NE for Sections 2, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, and 10 in an Amount of$30,775.00 and
Asplundh Tree Expert Company of Urbandale, Iowa for Sections 1, 4, and 6 in an Amount of
$64,779.00.
#2012-358 —Approving Pipeline Crossing Agreement for Water Main Project 2013-W-1 — Clark
Street at the UPRR Crossing.
#2012-359 — Approving Bid Award for Feedwater Heater #5 Replacement at Platte Generating
Station with Thermal Engineering International of Santa Fe Springs, CA in an Amount of
$401,750.00.
#2012-360 — Approving Bid Award for 5th Street Sanitary Sewer Improvements; Sewer Project
No. 201 2-S-3 with Van Kirk Brothers Contracting of Sutton, NE in an Amount of$1,734,105.93.
#2012-361 — Approving Standardizing on Allen-Bradley Electrical Components for Headworks
Improvements Project, WWTP-2013-1.
#2012-362 — Approving Pre-Selected Grit Systems for Headworks Improvements Project,
WWTP-2013-1.
Page 3,City Council Regular Meeting,December 18,2012
#2012-363 —Approving Interdepartmental Fund Transfer for Utility Relocation at the Broadwell
Avenue/Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railroad Crossing.
#2012-364 — Approving CentruyLink Participating Addendum in an Amount of$488.00. This
item was pulled from the agenda at the request of the Finance Department.
RESOLUTIONS:
#2012-365 — Consideration of Request from Bocho's, Inc. dba San Pedro's Mexican Restaurant,
2418 N. Webb Road, Suite A for a Class "I" Liquor License and Liquor Manager Designation
for Bernice Real, 2010 West 39th Street, Apt. A, Kearney, NE. This item related to the
aforementioned Public Hearing. Ms. Edwards explained the process of the denial to the LCC.
Answered were questions concerning stipulations.
Motion by Gericke, second by Niemann to deny Resolution #2012-365 based on the Police
Department report of a false application. Upon roll call vote, all voted aye. Motion adopted.
#2012-366 — Consideration of Agreement with NDOR for Fiscal Year 2013 Statewide Planning
Research (SPR) Agreement (Metropolitan Planning Organization Startup). Interim Public Works
Director Terry Brown reported that the Nebraska Department of Roads (NDOR) had reserved
planning dollars for the City for the formation of the Metropolitan Planning Organization
(MPO). The Planning Agreement between the City and the NDOR would provide financial
assistance for startup expenses for FY 2013 as a new MPO.
Motion by Dugan, second by Gericke to approve Resolution #2012-366. Upon roll call vote, all
voted aye. Motion adopted.
PAYMENT OF CLAIMS:
Motion by Dugan, second by Nickerson to approve the Claims for the period of November 28,
2012 through December 18, 2012, for a total amount of$7,129,635.92. Unanimously approved.
Councilmember Gericke recused himself from the meeting at 7:50 p.m.
RESOLUTIONS:
#2012-367 — Pre-84 Retirees — Public Safety Pension Plans — Remedy Request of Most Recent
Retiree Claim. Finance Director Jaye Monter reported that Resolution #2012-367 (A) would
direct City staff, the Police Pension Committee, and Sergeant Cole to recalculate Sergeant Cole's
lump sum pension benefit using a straight life annuity and reimbursement of the difference.
Resolution#2012-367 (B) would require no change in the pension paid to Sergeant Cole.
Ms. Monter introduced Robert Evnen — Attorney for Woods & Aitken of Lincoln and Terry
Galloway, Auditor for the city. City Attorney Robert Sivick explained the reasons for hiring
outside counsel with regards to this matter.
Page 4,City Council Regular Meeting,December 18,2012
Joyce Haase, 3024 Colonial Lane spoke in support of the reimbursement. Jarrett Daugherty,
President of the FOP and Kelly Mossman, Chairman of the Police Retirement Committee spoke
in favor of not requiring Sgt. Cole to make reimbursement. Mary Lanfear, 2128 North Custer
commented about litigation and the process of paying the pension.
Motion by Paulick, second by Minton to approve Resolution#2012-367 (B).
Discussion was held regarding previous retirees' pension payments. Comments were made
concerning time to gather more facts, possible litigation and moving too fast. Mr. Sivick
answered questions regarding state statutes on the time frame in which to pay out pension funds.
He also explained the process if part (A) of the Resolution was approved. Robert Evnen —
Attorney commented on the effect of postponing this item. He stated the Council could postpone
but would need to make a decision no later than January 2013.
Motion by Gilbert, second by Dugan to postpone a decision on Resolution #2012-367 to the
January 15, 2013 Study Session. Upon roll call vote, Councilmembers Minton, Dugan, Gilbert,
Hehnke, Donaldson, and Niemann voted aye. Councilmembers Paulick and Nickerson voted no.
Motion adopted.
#2012-368 —Pre-84 Retirees —Public Safety Pension Plans—Remedy of Past Claims for Police.
Finance Director Jaye Monter reported that Resolution #2012-368 (A) would direct City staff,
the Police Pension Committee, and the four Police retirees to recalculate their lump sum pension
benefit using a straight life annuity and reimbursement of the difference. Resolution #2012-368
(B) would require no change in the pension paid to the four Police retirees.
Discussion was held regarding the number of retirees. Ms. Monter stated there were 4 names
instead of 5 as mentioned at the December 11, 2012 meeting.
Motion by Gilbert, second by Dugan to postpone a decision on Resolution #2012-368 to the
January 15, 2013 Study Session. Upon roll call vote, all voted aye. Motion adopted.
ORDINANCES:
#9414—Pre-84 Retirees—Public Safety Pension Plans
Motion by Gilbert, second by Paulick to postpone Ordinance #9414 to the January 15, 2013
Study Session. Upon roll call vote, all voted aye. Motion adopted.
RESOLUTION:
#2012-369 — Pre-84 Retirees — Public Safety Pension Plans — City Budget Appropriation
Transfer. Finance Director Jaye Monter reported this would authorize city staff to transfer money
from the General Fund to the Police Fund to pay for the most recent retiree, Captain Pete
Kortum.
John Mayer, Chairman for the Fire Pension Committee commented on the separate pension
funds for the Police and Fire as stated in state statutes. He stated the Fire Pension Committee was
Page 5,City Council Regular Meeting,December 18,2012
not in favor of moving funds from the Fire Pension Fund to the Police Pension Fund. Explained
was the makeup and role of the Fire Pension Committee and how meetings were conducted.
Joyce Haase, 3024 Colonial Lane commented on the Fire Pension fund was to be used on
disabled Firefighters also.
Motion by Gilbert, second by Dugan to deny Resolution #2012-369. Upon roll call vote,
Councilmembers Minton, Paulick, Dugan, Gilbert, Donaldson, and Niemann voted aye.
Councilmembers Nickerson and Hehnke voted no. Motion adopted.
Council requested information for the Study Session on January 15, 2013. Discussion was held
regarding the process of submitting questions. Mayor stated City Administration would come up
with a process for Council to submit questions.
ADJOURNMENT: The meeting was adjourned at 9:11 p.m.
RaNae Edwards
City Clerk